Read Time: 7 min | Active Readers: 26,775

Welcome to Product Monk, a 3x/week newsletter where we share the case studies of the most exciting tech products.

We wrote these three stories last week, hope you love them ❤️:

• Walmart's 2022 Cost Optimization Strategy & Results!

• The Ultimate Guide to Product MVP Types

• Jio AirFiber launched: See problem statement, value proposition, and competition

PS: Every email has a quick feedback at the bottom. Would really appreciate it if you give feedback there. Gives us a general sense of how our case studies/emails have been received and how to improve on them.

🧃Juicy reads to check out

This section includes some relevant articles/videos, people to check out, and links you might find interesting from around Product management.

👉🏻 Have the Product Data. (Link)

👉🏻 Video: Product Management & Innovation with Productboard. (Link).

👉🏻 DOUBLE VISION: CHOOSING THE RIGHT APPROACH TO CAPTURE THE PRODUCT VISION (Link)

👩‍💼 Hot PM job postings added!

Find the latest PM jobs for apprentices, interns, and beginners at the end of this post. Read this case study to crack them!

McDonald's Redesign Strategy: All-Day Breakfast

In the ever-evolving landscape of the fast-food industry, adaptability and responsiveness to changing customer preferences are pivotal for success. McDonald's introduced an all-day breakfast in October 2015. The company began testing the concept in San Diego in April 2015. The test menu didn't include McGriddles and biscuits.

McDonald's, an emblematic fast-food giant, identified a critical demand among its patrons – the desire for breakfast items at any time of the day. This case study delves into the intricacies of this significant endeavor, shedding light on the meticulous research, innovative design, and thoughtful rollout phases that facilitated the triumphant adaptation of its menu.

The all-day breakfast menu included: Egg McMuffin, Sausage McMuffin, Hash browns, Biscuit sandwiches, hot cakes, McGriddles. 

The all-day breakfast menu was popular and helped McDonald's post higher-than-expected earnings in 2016. However, the company removed all-day breakfast from its national menu in 2020. The decision was made to improve service speed due to reduced staffing and a lack of dine-in traffic. 

I. Research Phase

In the research phase of this monumental undertaking, McDonald's left no stone unturned in their quest to comprehend the evolving needs and trends in the food-service industry. This comprehensive research laid the foundation for the successful introduction of All-Day Breakfast. Key aspects of their research included:

1. Customer Feedback

Listening to their customers, McDonald's discerned the resounding clamor for breakfast items that transcended the conventional morning hours. Through direct feedback, surveys, and in-depth analysis of customer comments, the company recognized that the appeal of breakfast items was not confined to the narrow window of traditional breakfast hours. People said, "I've been waiting 40 years for this"!. This invaluable insight from the very people who patronized their restaurants was the starting point of their redesign journey.

2. Market Analysis

McDonald's visionary approach extended to meticulously monitoring market trends. The company vigilantly tracked the shifting landscape of the food-service industry, where the all-day breakfast concept was gaining momentum. Recognizing the growing popularity of all-day breakfast offerings from both competitors and the burgeoning fast-casual restaurant industry, they identified an opportunity to meet a changing customer need. These observations, derived from market dynamics, played a pivotal role in steering their strategic direction.

McDonald's said the all-day breakfast launch was "successful". The company's first-quarter earnings in 2016 were higher than expected, which was attributed to the popularity of its breakfast. McDonald's U.S. same-store sales growth of 5.7% outperformed the rest of the fast food sandwich segment by 2.9 percentage points. 

3. Competitive Analysis

In a landscape teeming with competitors, McDonald's took a discerning look at their peers who had successfully ventured into the realm of extended breakfast hours. By examining the accomplishments of competitors, they gained a deeper understanding of consumer preferences and industry dynamics.

Through this analysis, they ascertained that the provision of breakfast items beyond the usual time frame had become not just a luxury but an industry standard. McDonald's recognized the need to adapt to this prevailing paradigm to remain competitive and relevant.

Jack in the Box, a competitor to McDonald’s in the US complained in Feb 2016: “a competitor's messaging around its launch of all-day breakfast had some impact on our results, particularly in the 10:30 a.m. to noon period.”. This competitor is safe to assume, is McDonald’s.

4. Operational Feasibility

Understanding that a mere desire to meet customer needs would not suffice, McDonald's delved into the practical aspects of implementing the All-Day Breakfast concept. Assessing the feasibility of adapting their kitchen and service processes was paramount. They recognized the need for operational changes and alterations in their kitchen setup to ensure the simultaneous preparation of breakfast and non-breakfast items.

This deep dive into operations was a pragmatic step to ensure the smooth execution of their redesign, ensuring that the transition to All-Day Breakfast would not disrupt the overall service and experience for customers.

II. Design Phase

The design phase of McDonald's All-Day Breakfast initiative was a critical juncture where the insights gathered from the extensive research were transformed into actionable strategies and tangible changes. This phase was marked by a series of thoughtful design decisions that would set the stage for the successful rollout of this groundbreaking offering. Key design aspects included:

1. Menu Adaptation

Building upon the wealth of information garnered from customer feedback and market analysis, McDonald's embarked on a fundamental menu redesign. This pivotal decision was at the core of the entire initiative. They conceived a menu that would seamlessly allow the preparation of breakfast items alongside the regular menu throughout the day.

This redesign was not merely about expanding operating hours; it was about rethinking and reshaping the menu to provide customers with the freedom to choose breakfast items at any time. This bold step required careful consideration of ingredients, preparation methods, and kitchen logistics to ensure a harmonious coexistence of breakfast and non-breakfast items.

2. Operational Changes

Understanding that the successful execution of All-Day Breakfast was not just a matter of changing the menu but also a reimagining of kitchen operations, McDonald's introduced a series of operational changes. Kitchen equipment and processes were adjusted to accommodate the simultaneous preparation of breakfast and non-breakfast items.

This meant retraining kitchen staff and reconfiguring kitchen layouts to ensure a smooth and efficient workflow. The operational changes were essential to maintain the quality, speed, and accuracy of service, ensuring that customers received their orders promptly, irrespective of their breakfast cravings.

3. Marketing Campaign

The design phase was not confined to culinary innovations alone. McDonald's recognized the importance of communicating the essence of All-Day Breakfast to their customer base. To achieve this, they launched a compelling marketing campaign that highlighted the availability of All-Day Breakfast.

This campaign was designed to create awareness and anticipation, effectively conveying the message that customers could now enjoy their favorite breakfast items at any hour. The marketing campaign was instrumental in generating enthusiasm and curiosity, setting the stage for a smooth transition.

4. Menu Promotion

Within the redesigned menu, McDonald's identified the need to promote specific breakfast items as the key components of the All-Day Breakfast experience. Breakfast classics like the Egg McMuffin, hotcakes, and hash browns were strategically highlighted. These items, often beloved by customers, served as anchors of the All-Day Breakfast concept, attracting both loyal fans and newcomers alike.

This promotion ensured that the menu adaptation was not just about availability but also about celebrating the cherished breakfast items that made McDonald's a breakfast destination.

III. Rollout Phase

The rollout phase of McDonald's All-Day Breakfast initiative was a well-orchestrated and pivotal stage where the meticulous planning and design decisions were translated into real-world actions. This phase was marked by several key strategies that were instrumental in ensuring the successful implementation and acceptance of All-Day Breakfast. The strategies employed included:

1. Gradual Introduction

Recognizing the immense scope and complexity of the All-Day Breakfast rollout, McDonald's opted for a gradual introduction. This approach allowed for a controlled and well-managed transition across the United States. Individual restaurants were given the flexibility to implement the changes at their own pace based on their operational capacity.

This measured approach ensured that each location had the necessary resources, training, and equipment in place before offering All-Day Breakfast. It prevented a rushed, chaotic rollout and guaranteed a consistent and quality experience for customers.

2. Employee Training

The introduction of All-Day Breakfast demanded a skilled and adaptable workforce. McDonald's understood that the success of this initiative hinged on the ability of their employees to manage the dual menu effectively and maintain the high service quality that customers expected. To this end, McDonald's provided comprehensive training to its employees.

Staff members were educated on the intricacies of the redesigned menu, the adjusted kitchen operations, and the new workflow. This training not only ensured that employees were well-equipped to deliver on the promises of All-Day Breakfast but also contributed to their job satisfaction and confidence.

3. Customer Communication

Effective communication with customers was a linchpin of the All-Day Breakfast rollout. McDonald's recognized the importance of ensuring that their patrons were well-informed about the extended breakfast hours. To achieve this, in-store signage was strategically placed to convey the message that breakfast items were available throughout the day.

Additionally, McDonald's launched advertising campaigns that highlighted the All-Day Breakfast concept, its benefits, and the newfound freedom for customers to enjoy breakfast at any time. This clear and consistent communication fostered understanding and anticipation among customers, who were eager to experience the extended breakfast hours.

4. Performance Monitoring

The final strategy of the rollout phase involved continuous performance monitoring. McDonald's was committed to assessing the impact of the changes on various fronts, including customer satisfaction, operational efficiency, and sales.

This meticulous monitoring allowed the company to make real-time adjustments where necessary and fine-tune the All-Day Breakfast experience. It ensured that the initiative was not merely introduced but also continuously improved to meet and exceed customer expectations.

Outcome

McDonald's All-Day Breakfast was considered a successful redesign. It met changing customer needs by offering breakfast items throughout the day, addressing customer demand for flexibility in meal choices.

This move contributed to increased sales and improved customer satisfaction. However, there were operational challenges for some locations, and not all breakfast items were available throughout the day due to kitchen limitations.

Key Takeaway for Product Managers

1. Thorough research is essential to understand changing customer needs and industry trends.

2. Redesigns should address customer demand and convenience while considering operational feasibility.

3. Gradual introduction and employee training are crucial for successful rollout.

4. Effective communication with customers is essential to inform them of menu changes and extended hours.

👩‍💼 Hot PM Jobs for Starters!

1. Product Management Apprenticeship

Pinterest
Apply

2. 2024 Entry Level: Product Manager

IBM
Remote
Apply

3. Product Manager (BnB) Intern

Union Living
Mumbai, India
Apply